1852 April 1st Thursday. Another April fool day and I don’t
know of a bigger one than myself except Orinthia
She made some beet & pepper pies for the boys but instead of
making a fool of them she made one of herself for they would not taste them
Oakes A carried Orinthia & self to Mr Elijah Howards on his way
to N Bridgewater & spent the evening there Orinthia will spend the
night We went into Augustas this forenoon to fool her
Her sister Emeline is there
Evelina enjoyed April Fool’s Day, or All Fools Day, as people often called it at the time. The previous year she had played a prank on her sisters-in-law; this year, she tried to trick her young neighbor, Augusta Gilmore. And this time, it would seem that someone played a trick on her, as “she didn’t know a bigger fool..” than herself. But she stifled her embarrassment, deflecting it off onto her friend, Orinthia Foss, whose trick on the Ames boys failed. They wouldn’t eat her trick pies, making Orinthia the greater fool of the day.
There were a few guidelines that most people understood about jokes played on April 1st. They had to be harmless pranks, for one. The jokes were meant to embarrass, not to injure or insult. They lacked the menace that pranks later played on Halloween typically carried, for instance. They were meant as fun, the only cost of which was someone else’s dignity.
Another, more particular rule was that tricks could only be played in the morning. After the clocks had struck noon, the pranks were no longer fair play. Anyone playing a prank in the afternoon was considered foolish, and one playground retort to anyone who tried it was: “April’s gone and May’s come; You’re a fool and I’m none!”**Orinthia’s trick on the Ames boys would have happened right at midday and, with the clock striking twelve, she missed the morning window.